Preface
Introduction: The Cost of Silence
- A Few Notes Before You Start
- Putting It to Work
- Part One: The Awkwardness Problem
1. The Cost of Avoided Feedback
- When Nobody Says Anything
- Put Numbers on It
- The Workshop Trap
- A Lesson From My Dad
2. Why Feedback Is Awkward (and Why Most “Fixes” Fail)
- Type One: Manager Dread
- Type Two: Receiver Defensiveness
- Type Three: HR’s Protective Instinct
- Type Four: Not My Place
- Why the Usual Fixes Fail
- What Helps Instead: Honest Feedback
- What This Means for Leaders
- What This Means for the Employee
3. Hearing vs. Receiving
- Seven Reasons People Don’t Receive Feedback
- Johnny Couldn’t Receive the Feedback
- The Day I Was Put on a PIP
- The Credentialing Panel Story
- Heard or Received? How to Tell
- The PAUSE Protocol
- Part Two: For Leaders and HR — Build the Culture
4. Diagnose Your Feedback Culture
- How to Gather the Data
- Look for Trends
- Aftermath Matters More Than the Others
- How to Read the Diagnosis
- Common Patterns and What They Suggest
- Put Your Reports Next to Your Diamond
5. The 90-Day Rollout
- Days 1–14: Pick the Pilot
- Days 15–45: Train the Managers and Establish the Practices
- Days 46–75: Measure the Progress
- Days 76–90: Decide and Communicate
- Watch for the Common Rollout Failures
6. Beyond Review Time: Feedback as Daily Rhythm
- No Surprises
- Say It When You See It
- Build the Relationship Before You Need It
- Make Feedback Part of the Culture
- Keeping the Instinct Alive
- Five Minutes on Friday
7. When Feedback Goes Wrong: How to Repair It
- The First 24 Hours
- What Actually Went Wrong
- The Repair Belongs to the Manager
- When to Call Legal
- So What Happened with Steve?
- Part Three: For Managers — The Conversations
8. Navigating a Hard Conversation Without Dread
- Before You Walk In
- The Five Steps
- What It Sounds Like: Three Sample Conversations
- Your Dread, Their Reactions
9. Psychological Safety: Making It Safe to Be Honest
- The Four Signals You Send Without Knowing It
- How Safe Does Your Team Feel?
- How to Make It Safer
- Why It Matters
10. PIPs and the Conversations Everyone Dreads
- What a PIP Actually Is
- Before the PIP
- Designing a Fair PIP
- Delivering the PIP, and the Midpoint Check-In
- The Two Endings
- What Darlene Did Right
- Part Four: For Everyone — Receive and Grow
11. Receive Feedback Without Going Defensive, and Grow From It
- The Four R’s
- Why We Go Defensive
- The PAUSE Protocol, Expanded
- Taking Feedback vs. Taking It Personally
- Deciding What to Act On
- Deciding What to Set Aside
- The Long Arc
Conclusion: From Awkward to Honest
- What We Did Together
- What I Promised You
- Where to Go Next
- Your Turn
- Appendix: Tools to Use Right Away
- Using These with Your Team
- Chapter 3: Hearing vs. Receiving
- Chapter 4: Diagnose Your Feedback Culture
- Chapter 6: Beyond Review Time: Feedback as Daily Rhythm
- Chapter 7: When Feedback Goes Wrong: How to Repair It
- Chapter 8: Navigating a Hard Conversation Without Dread
- Chapter 11: Receive Feedback Without Going Defensive, and Grow From It