Quality in Translation
Quality in Translation
A Multi-Threaded Fabric
About the Book
The subtitle of this volume reflects the idea that quality in translation entails a multi-dimensionality, a multi-threaded fabric of sorts. Just as strong fabric consists in the warp and weft of opposing threads, so in Bible translation the multiple facets of translation should be brought together in a holism. This holism entails balancing the tension of the objective details of the Biblical text and the languages into which we translate, and the subjective framing of our aspirations for its Christian use among the peoples of the world.
The volume practices frontier science in the sense that the authors put forward ideas that are new, or ideas that are hypotheses that are not supported by years of scientific experience or theoretical reflection. This is in contrast to consensus science that refers to data, models, ideas, and laws that are widely accepted. Rather, authors employ ideas emerging out of the changing cultural contexts of the Global North and South and adapt them for use in pursuing quality in translation. They also engage with the issues around changing technology and how this will affect ways of measuring quality.
The need to adapt to changing cultural complexes has been a perennial challenge for Christianity beginning with its spread across the countries around the Mediterranean and into the countries of Europe. As it has engaged with the cultural complexes of its day, it has required much thought, writing, and scholarship. This is no less true in our day as we engage around the issue of quality in translation in the context of the interaction of the Christian faith and the emerging cultural turns in the Global North and South. This involves risk in part because we, as authors, do not have prescribed answers, and in part because the proposed solutions may invite disagreement. Nevertheless, we believe that engaging with the difficulty of the tension is part of the role of scholarship, and that by engaging with this tension we may extend the boundaries of our knowledge about quality in translation.
- 1.Quality in Translation: The Warp and Weft of Subjective and Objective Threads
- 1.1Why revisit quality in translation?
- 1.2Some Caveats
- 1.3Bible translation: between modernity and post-modernity
- 1.4Quality as a holism
- 1.5The post-colonial turn
- 1.6Proselytes and converts
- 1.7What is the meta-narrative of the BTM?
- 2.Re-modeling quality: A comparison of implicit values revealed by translation metaphors
- 2.2Mental Models and Hermeneutics
- 2.3Science model
- 2.4Art model
- 2.5Craft model
- 2.6Dialogue model
- 2.7Journey model
- 2.8Mission model
- 2.9Tension points for quality assurance
- 3.“… And Behold, Angels Came and Ministered to Him.”
- 3.1A case study in text interpretation
- 3.2The multidimensional nature of text, meaning, and context
- 3.3Multiperspectival text analysis
- 3.4Main results of a multiperspectival reading of Matthew 4:1-11
- 3.5Interpreting the meaning and function of idou in Matthew 4:11b
- 3.6Application to translation
- 4.Scripture, or Translations of Scripture? Septuagint, Doctrines of Scripture, and Bible Translation Today
- 4.2The Nature of the LXX
- 4.3The use of the LXX in the Apostolic Period
- 4.4The LXX Conundrum
- 4.5Recent Discussions About Doctrines of Scripture
- 4.6Toward a New Theological and Hermeneutical Paradigm of Scripture
- 4.7What, Then, of Quality in Translation?
- 5.Theology and Hermeneutics: From Translation Challenge to Unrealized Potential
- 5.2The challenge of theology in Bible translation
- 5.3Empowering Bible translators
- 5.4The BTM joining in with the Holy Spirit
- 6.Multimodality In Bible Translation: Could It Contribute To Quality Assurance?
- 6.1Introduction: the mandate of the ETEN Innovation Lab on Quality Assurance
- 6.2Recommendation 1: Multimodality and multimedia
- 6.3Defining multimodal translation
- 6.4Recommendation 2: An expanded role for the Church in Bible translation
- 6.5Recommendation 3: Different quality assurance tools and processes
- 7.A Method for Exegeting Emotions in the Bible for Higher Quality Translation
- 7.2Foundations of emotion studies
- 7.3Emotion and society
- 7.4Emotion and language
- 7.5How to exegete emotions in the Bible
- 7.6Case study: Mark 7:24-30
- 8.Euphony as a Central Component of Quality
- 8.2Theoretical Considerations: Relevance Theory
- 8.3Translations with Limited Aesthetic Appeal
- 8.4A Literary Functional Equivalent Approach
- 8.5A Tibetan Literary Translation Experience
- 8.6Conclusions and Recommendations
- 9.Tacit Linguistic Knowledge is Not Enough: Participatory Methods to Improve Quality in Bible Translation
- 9.2Can you not just rely on native speaker intuition?
- 9.3Are there also mistranslations in oral Scripture?
- 9.4Won’t translators become aware of language structures through the normal translation process?
- 9.5Isn’t the Scripture adequate for the language communities?
- 9.6Won’t machine translation tools make Scripture adequate?
- 9.7Why is a study of the sound system key to developing a readable orthography?
- 9.8Why is the study of discourse key to making a natural, asthetic, coherent and accurate Bible text?
- 9.9In what ways have participatory studies on the part of the mother-tongue speaker actually improved the quality of the Bible text?
- 10.African Access to a Quality Bible Translation
- 10.2Roadblock 1 for Borana language
- 10.3Roadblock 2 for the Dangme language
- 10.4Roadblock 3 for Maasai language
- 10.5Orthography Recommendations: Support comprehensibility of Scripture text
- 11.Translating the Bible with People for People: How Current Anthropological Insights contribute to Quality
- 11.2Anthropological theory and Bible translation
- 11.3Towards a theologically engaged anthropology
- 11.4Reflexive practice
- 11.5Questioning culture
- 11.6Organising Bible translation
- 11.7What is quality in Bible translation?
- 11.8Semiotics in Bible translation
- 11.9Language and semiotic ideologies
- 11.10Turning to ontology
- 11.11Ontonic words in northwestern Benin
- 11.12Awkward equivalence in translation
- 11.13Semiotic ideologies and media
- 12.Artificial Intelligence Tools as Quality Assessment Copilots
- 12.2Expectations and workflows
- 12.3Anchors in reality
- 12.4Methods of assessment
- 12.5Evidence from field trials
- 12.6Future Work
- 13.Lost in Translation: Navigating the Intersection of Humanity and Technology in Bible Translation
- 13.21. What problem is the technology trying to solve? 2. Whose problem is it?
- 13.33. Who might be most seriously harmed by a technological solution? 4. What new problems might be created because we have solved this problem?
- 13.45. What sort of people and institutions might acquire special power because of this change?
- 13.56. What changes in language are being enforced by new technologies?
- 14.Summary, Synthesis, and Future Research
- 14.3Future Research
- 15.Appendix: Re-modeling quality: A comparison of implicit values revealed by translation metaphors
- 15.1Illustrative Quotes
- 16.Appendix: “… And Behold, Angels Came and Ministered to Him.”
- 16.1CONTEXT OF COMMUNICATION
- 16.2LITERARY FORM
- 16.3COMMUNICATIVE PURPOSE(S)
- 16.4TEXTUAL COMPOSITION
- 16.5COMMUNICATED CONTENT
- 16.6PRAGMATIC FUNCTION
- 16.7TEXT RECEPTION AND INTERPRETATION
- 17.Appendix: Tacit Linguistic Knowledge is Not Enough: Participatory Methods to Improve Quality in Bible Translation
This book is published on Leanpub by Pike Center
Pike Center for Integrative Scholarship is an initiative of SIL International that builds capacity for language development through scholarship. SIL works alongside ethnolinguistic communities as they discover how language development addresses the challenging areas of their daily lives—social, cultural, political, economic and spiritual.
One of Pike Center’s strategies for building capacity is to grow the needed bodies of knowledge through its Agile Publishing program. We are using this lean publishing platform to give our affiliated scholars a platform for developing and refining new contributions to growing bodies of knowledge that support the language development movement. Many of our titles are still in a preliminary stage of development. Others are finished but have such a narrow audience that we have not elected to turn them into print books. Still others have reached the maturity of becoming a print book; in such cases, this is indicated by a link on the landing page for the book.
All of the revenues generated through sales on this site are directed to the Pike Center to support the on-going research activities of its affiliated scholars. Naming a higher price when you purchase one of our books is a way of contributing to this cause. Or you may go to the Pike Center website to make a donation that will receive a tax-deductible receipt.
The Leanpub 60 Day 100% Happiness Guarantee
Within 60 days of purchase you can get a 100% refund on any Leanpub purchase, in two clicks.
Now, this is technically risky for us, since you'll have the book or course files either way. But we're so confident in our products and services, and in our authors and readers, that we're happy to offer a full money back guarantee for everything we sell.
You can only find out how good something is by trying it, and because of our 100% money back guarantee there's literally no risk to do so!
So, there's no reason not to click the Add to Cart button, is there?
See full terms...
80% Royalties. Earn $16 on a $20 book.
We pay 80% royalties. That's not a typo: you earn $16 on a $20 sale. If we sell 5000 non-refunded copies of your book or course for $20, you'll earn $80,000.
(Yes, some authors have already earned much more than that on Leanpub.)
In fact, authors have earnedover $12 millionwriting, publishing and selling on Leanpub.
Learn more about writing on Leanpub
Free Updates. DRM Free.
If you buy a Leanpub book, you get free updates for as long as the author updates the book! Many authors use Leanpub to publish their books in-progress, while they are writing them. All readers get free updates, regardless of when they bought the book or how much they paid (including free).
Most Leanpub books are available in PDF (for computers) and EPUB (for phones, tablets and Kindle). The formats that a book includes are shown at the top right corner of this page.
Finally, Leanpub books don't have any DRM copy-protection nonsense, so you can easily read them on any supported device.